James Westbrook, Without a Crystal Ball LLC, Halo Beauty Partners LLC and Tatiana Westbrook: Defendant: Katie Joy Paulson, Does 1 through 100, inclusive and Does 1-100: Case Number: 2:2020cv01606: Filed: October 30, 2020: Court: US District Court for the Western District of Washington: Presiding Judge: Barbara J Rothstein: Nature of Suit . If Lindsie is suppose to be a strong woman (which she is not) hence having her friend speak for her. Sometimes, I think you have to prove you actually suffered emotional distress usually by using things like medical bills and and expert testimony and stuff. In concluding that defendants had expressly aimed their conduct at California, the Court noted the following factors were significant: that defendants had reached out directly by telephone to sources in California; that the article "concerned the California activities of a California resident," and contained "various facts that gave the article a California focus"; that National Enquirer sold 600,000 copies of the article in California, out of a total nationwide circulation of approximately 5 millionalmost twice as many as in the next highest State; and that the contents in the article were alleged to have caused an injury "to the plaintiff's reputation in the estimation of the California public," and specifically, "impugned the professionalism of an entertainer whose television career was centered in California." See Burger King Corp., 471 U.S. at 472-76; Schwarzenegger, 374 F.3d at 802. Trisha Faulkner has been a freelance writer for a decade with a focus on news/reporting for the last three years. Use of these names, logos, and brands does not imply endorsement unless specified. That potato (Truth Sleuth aka Ali) really woke up this morning and is right back on Twitter first thing in the morning talking about Katie again. Swanson claims the Westbrooks either showed no interest in his activities or actively asked him to "stand down" from expanding Halo Beauty. Swanson also says the Westbrooks blocked planned skincare product launches through Halo Beauty and forced the company to "coast" throughout the rest of 2019, after the launch of Tati Beauty in October 2019. In her spare time, she enjoys raising awareness about autism and spending time with her two children. Katie Joy (born November 19, 1978 (1978-11-19) [age 44]), also known as Without a Crystal Ball, covers a variety of topics including reality tv, celebrity gossip, trending news, crime, personal vlogs & More. He also appeared on TheEllenShow on November 14, 2016. On August 1, 2017, Swanson says he met with the Westbrooks at his home and that the two asked him to reconsider the company's future and ownership structure. On June 30th, Tati released another video after taking a break from Youtube for almost 2 months. all of this is public record."). Without a Crystal Ball is the "fruit Salad" channel of YouTube. Wash. Mar. 38-1, 5. Critically, almost none of the few Washington references in Defendants' videos are connected to the underlying defamation claims in this case. Pls.' Share to Reddit. Subscribe to Justia's Free Newsletters featuring summaries of federal and state court opinions. We assemb, Rihanna has signed Johnny Depp as special guest of, According to his latest post on Twitter, Elon stat, Finally After 6 years of pause in music indus, Two influencers from New Zealand who had be, Are you ready for these Halloween Decor ideas, Check our take on Gen Z changing the game of socia, If replying with a thumbs up emoji i, This error message is only visible to WordPress admins, Unleashing the Power of JoJo Siwa: How She Became a Social Media Sensation and Influencer Marketing Superstar, TikToks Deinfluence Trend: Changing the Face of Influencer Marketing, Everything You Wonder About Lensa AI Portraits, Why Starting Your Own Business in College Important, Nature Photographers to Follow For Inspiration. Without a Crystal Ball LLC, Katie Joy Paulson with JURY DEMAND (Receipt # AWAWDC-6707588), filed by James Westbrook, Tatiana Westbrook, Halo Beauty Partners . Tati is just trying to cough shit up so she looks like an innocent snowflake, damsel in distress from Katie Joy who got like 10k views on a video talking about her. James Charles Dickinson (born: May 23, 1999 (1999-05-23) [age 23]), formerly known online as JaysCoding and JCharlesBeauty, is an American YouTuber, makeup artist, model, and vlogger. Stay up to date with what you want to know. When a defendant moves to dismiss for lack of personal jurisdiction, "the plaintiff bears the burden of demonstrating that jurisdiction is appropriate." All of a plaintiff's uncontroverted allegations are taken as true, and factual disputes are to be resolved in plaintiff's favor. Br. Hope she isnt financially destroyed being sued but learns the ugly she chooses to state about others and stops! 264 following. Remember Joy Sparkles? Unlike similar channels who merely cover drama, KJ has drawn the ire of many notable figures due to her fabrication of vicious rumors and malicious actions toward other . . I kinda think that the COVID exuse was a lie and that it was an exuse for all the mess happening behind the scene. Hes no better than rest of world if he did wrong then be a man and own up n face the music. It's poetic. Perez Hilton reported in 2020, that "Beauty guru Tati Westbrook is reportedly suing a fellow YouTuber named Katie Joy for defamation." At the time, the outlet reported that Katie Joy warned bloggers on Instagram, . 26 & 27. Kj was warned to be careful and to drop as a pending case was in the background.Most of it is public property but allegedly can only cover you for so much. . She's a wonderful friend with a kind heart & she's incredibly loyal. Click to reveal R. Civ. . Mot. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. See Decls. Because the Court grants Defendants' motion to dismiss on these grounds, it does not reach Defendants' remaining challenges to the Complaint. . This is where youll need it.) 2d 1140, 1147 (W.D. Search the history of over 797 billion Other than a brief reference Paulson makes to Ms. Westbrook's "small tax warrant" in 2003 in Washingtonlasting mere seconds of the hours and hours of video at issuethe Court was unable to identify any explicit references to Washington that might arguably impugn the Westbrooks' reputation. 7,379 posts. In October 2020, Tati Westbrook filed a lawsuit against a creator named Katie Joy, who runs the channel Without A Crystal Ball, arguing that her coverage of Westbrook was defamatory. He likes to win. Dkt. Casetext, Inc. and Casetext are not a law firm and do not provide legal advice. She has repeatedly LIED about other content Creators on the Platform (YouTube) and Created a Pathological Lie that even she believes to be True. nolan is in martial bliss, but reality smacked him in the face when he came back to deal with a unruly eight-year-old son and living arrangements; and also, telling the family he's . On a side note Im by far not a fan of WOACB at all but I do feel sorry for the fact she is a parent of a child with extra needs and its tough. These videos are presented as "exposs" covering a range of subjects, including: (1) a public dispute between Ms. Westbrook and a rival/fellow "beauty celebrity" James Charles; (2) the safety and efficacy of Halo vitamin products, which Paulson has referred to as "snake oil"; (3) the personal and business history of the Westbrooks, including alleged legal disputes and business failures; and (4) a lawsuit filed in October 2020 in Los Angeles Superior Court by Plaintiffs' "business partner" Clark Swanson, against Halo Beauty, Inc., a company affiliated with Plaintiffs. on the Internet. Tati hasnt uploaded since then. 4. . #1. The public feud between Tati Westbrook and her former protege James Charles played out for the world to see. 1. level 1. He is a partner at Halo and part of the lawsuit. Previous Video: https://youtu.be/golrVYwR_6c TATI/WOACB LAWSUIT PLAYLIST: https://bit.ly/3l1XpnH HALO BEAUTY LAWSUIT PLAYLIST: http://bit.ly/3nGmu8S . All rights reserved. of Lori Ann Barnhart, Dkt. Im getting caught up on the archived videos she has removed about Tati and wow ahaha I had never really watched much from her because she seemed a little off. See id., 50-114; Plaintiffs' Civil Cover Sheet, Dkt. Without A Crystal Ball claims Tati destroyed James's career & caused him millions of dollars in her video, which Tati claims is a lie. It has declined to exercise jurisdiction, however, even where almost 20% of a defendant's total circulation was located in the forum, where plaintiff did "not establish that [defendant] expressly aimed at" the forum or "tailored the website to attract [forum-specific] traffic." But this wasnt the case with her first product. just good music, outfits, photos & memories lets GOOOO https://t.co/Au7pJCOt1X, James Charles (@jamescharles) January 3, 2020. Katie Joy has until Dec 3rd 2020 in order to response to Tati and James Westbrook's lawsuit. She seems green with envy honestly. Defendants have an estimated 135,000 YouTube followers. Beauty YouTuber Tati Westbrook has opened up about her experiences with YouTube stars Shane Dawson and Jeffree Star in a 40-minute video uploaded June 30, saying the two "used, coerced, and . General Principles on a Motion to Dismiss for Lack of Personal Jurisdiction. Tati Westbrook and husband James are facing a new lawsuit. Without a Crystal Ball a.k.a. Periodt. She's so dumb she doesn't even understand who has the burden of proof. Of course the Bye Sister fallout will have affected sales- and lets not forget that the manufacturing/shipping of Halo had to stop when Covid arrived- but that's not what they're asking about. 571 U.S. at 290. Helicopteros Nacionales de Colom., S.A. v. Hall, 466 U.S. 408, 415-416 (1984). Plaintiff Halo Beauty Partners ("Halo"), a Nevada limited liability company, is a "nutraceuticals company that produces products formulated to support hair, skin, and nail health." Link, Enjoy it while it lasts. INFLOW (Influencers of The World) is a platform that actively brings together partner brands with leading bloggers, digital influencers, social media content creators and digital trendsetters from all over the world. Id., 22. He noted they didnt fear them as he considered going to court to be a sport. Performance & security by Cloudflare. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website. would not have occurred but for the fact that the defendants wrote an article for publication in California that was read by a large number of California citizens." . No. Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. According to Insider, Tati and James have actively hindered Clark from further expanding the company. 93.113.1.133 She enjoys writing about the Showtime series Shameless, CBSs Survivor, Netflix, TOWIE, and some entertainment/celebrity news. She's been through a lot the past few years & right now she's going through a divorce. Anyone that follows me knows that I rarely report on her family because of my friendship with her.. All of my videos are my findings, unless stated otherwise, and not to be taken as 100% fact.#WithoutACrystalBall #WOACB #TatiWestbrook The lawsuit is about the impact that WOACB had. Her response to the lawsuit included the screenshots of several tweets. As we previously reported, Todd admitted that he wasn't afraid to get a little dirty via a lawsuit. So recently, I saw Tati's lawyer on Twitter people if they stopped purchasing Halo Beauty due to Katie's numerous but the issue with this is that Tati & her lawyers are failing to take into consideration is that many people stopped supporting her after people realized just how ridiculous the bye sisters video truly was and it really was just about the supplements and her manipulative apology video. Katie is worse. She's dotty. So we will have to wait for their response - which was usually missing in Katie's videos whenever she talks about Tati. at 4. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. 2. Without crystal ball Tati Westbrook indictment of defamation Natalie Kennett was caught on June 2, 2022 during the criticism of Tati Westbrook. I never got into her content because i absolutely cannot stand her voice but i watched some of her myka stauffer videos. 2018)); Handsome Music, LLC v. Etoro USA LLC, 2020 WL 8455111, at *9 (C.D. b. Furthermore, because the Barnhart declaration is not material to the Court's ruling on jurisdiction, the integrity of these proceedings is not implicated to the extent that Defendants contend. Share to Pinterest. Schwarzenegger v. Fred Martin Motor Co., 374 F.3d 797, 800 (9th Cir. I don't support Tati but that sure as hell doesn't have anything to do with Katie Joy,only heard of her cause of this drama so wuuut. Journalist?yeah ok. This case is DISMISSED without prejudice. What I do believe is that the case was firstly started around the launch of the first video that was done and the coverage of husband James. Well, it's . Mavrix Photo, Inc. v. Brand Techs., Inc., 647 F.3d 1218, 1228 (9th Cir. A recent Instagram post Katie shared on Sunday, Nov. 1, 2020 . Uplevel BACK 295.9M . by HiSistersByeSisters Mon Nov 09, 2020 7:51 pm, Post The Court takes as true Plaintiffs' barebones claim that "Defendants' viewership includes residents of Washington," but that factor alone is insufficient to support their bid for jurisdiction. For money. Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. She noted that court documents revealed it was Kyle and his ex-wife that reported Todd and Julie to the IRS. Your email address will not be published. In . Shame on you Ali. 2:20-cv-1606 (W.D. There are several actions that could trigger this block including submitting a certain word or phrase, a SQL command or malformed data. by HiSistersByeSisters Mon Nov 09, 2020 5:36 pm, Post In the new video, she spoke about her business partner Clark Swanson suing her and her husband. It alleges the Westbrooks committed fraud, negligence, and breach of fiduciary duty as Halo Beauty owners. Theyre not claiming theres only one. West graduated from a local Log In Sign Up. The evidence demonstrates, however, that Paulson conducted "several different searches," using general internet search engines, looking "all over the place . "At first, when I sat down to edit, it would be a twelve-hour process," she recalled in 2015, "Beauty tutorials still take a long time, but I've been able to get this down to . There's a new twist in the neverending YouTube beauty community drama. Well on Dec 18,2020 If I have to court date correct, that is when the Motion for Preservation of Evidence will take place to the Tati and James Westbrook vs WOACB (Without A Crystal Ball) AKA Katie Joy. I do not own all of this content, and this info is all public knowledge. Every case is different. Also Im just a law student not a lawyer, and Ive only worked on a few emotional distress cases so dont take my words as law lol. The cases demonstrate that the ultimate question of when defendants "expressly aim" their suit-related conduct at a forum state is intensely fact-specific. jkiOjkiD>mfAio ilwzS' Ribbon cutting ceremony formally opens Tupelo Campus Academic and Student Center Staff Reports Itawamba Community College for mally opened its Academic and Katie Joy is a vile person. by StalkingMyWholeLife Mon Nov 09, 2020 5:05 am, Post Defendants have an estimated . In the absence of applicable federal law, jurisdiction is governed by the long-arm statute of the state in which the court sits. He's seeking damages greater than $25,000. She is pathetic. MPEG4 . of T. Westbrook, 11 (quoting May 31, 2019 video "Sephora Arrived at My House! She needs to log off social media and check into a mental hospital. After the video was posted, Tati, while being sued by her business partner, sued Without A Crystal Ball for fake news & harassment. YouTube's OG beauty vlogger Tati Westbrook has returned to the spotlight after more than a year in the shadows. Id. Great that Todd Chrisley is suing her! To comply with the requirements of due process, a plaintiff must demonstrate "(1) that the non-resident defendant has established 'minimum contacts' with the forum state; and (2) that the exercise of personal jurisdiction comports with the traditional notions of 'fair play and substantial justice.'" The Westbrooks did not respond to Insider's request for comment and have not responded to the lawsuit yet, either. She claims to have over 9 million followers on YouTube alone. Katie Joys response suggests shes done reporting on the drama between Todd and Lindsie Chrisley out of response for her friend. Id., 5. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. And, keep coming back for the latest on the Chrisley family. In her Without a Crystal Ball vlog on YouTube, Katie is careful to always mention that she shares her opinion. Under this test, courts are to determine whether the defendant "(1) committed an intentional act, (2) expressly aimed at the forum state, (3) causing harm that the defendant knows is likely to be suffered in the forum state." Even Plaintiffs deny, however, that "Plaintiffs' domicile is relevant to the inquiry of whether personal jurisdiction exists over Defendants," and furthermore, the Court, as it must for purposes of this motion, takes Plaintiffs' allegations concerning their domicile as true. Opp. Thats the longest run-on sentence ive ever seen. "Ms. Paulson published numerous videos and other content maligning Plaintiffs in this case." This hearing will be conducted via ZoomGov, courtroom Deputy will provide counsel with Zoom information. All are welcome! Shane even went live on Instagram bashing Tati, it wasnt pretty. Beauty YouTuber and entrepreneur Tati Westbrook is being sued by her Halo Beauty business partner, court documents reveal. Westbrook said that she sold her Los Angeles home and her condo to support the ongoing litigation. Required fields are marked *. Id. Be the first one to, Tati Westbrook lawsuit complaint against Without a Crystal Ball, westbrook-et-al-v-paulson-et-al-wawdce-20-01606-0001.0, Advanced embedding details, examples, and help, Terms of Service (last updated 12/31/2014). By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Shes a strong woman that stands on her own. She added. The rabbit hole is deep and the dumpster is on fire right now in real time because KJ livestreamed her entire mental breakdown this week. I needed some diversion. . This is where the business gets involved. The funniest lie so far, she says that shes a reporter! These numbers can then be compared to the numbers that HB would have re reduction of orders and allow them to determine X% being due to WOACB. Built in 2016, this 6,281 square-foot home with 5 bedrooms and 7 bathrooms is priced at nearly $4 million. Full title:TATIANA WESTBROOK, an individual; JAMES WESTBROOK, an individual; HALO, Court:UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT WESTERN DISTRICT OF WASHINGTON AT SEATTLE. The channel is most well known for the coverage for Christian Fundamentalism, specifically fundie families such as the Bairds, the Schofields and the Duggars. Swanson claims he and the Westbrooks initially split Halo Beauty 50/50, and that the Westbrooks convinced him to give them 2/3 ownership in exchange for Tati promising to launch her future cosmetics, skincare, and fragrance lines with Halo Beauty. Todd Chrisley revealed his plans to sue Katie Joy of Without A Crystal Ball on his podcast Chrisley Confessions. The Court declines to rule on Defendants' Motion for Sanctions for several reasons. She is dangerous and disgusting with all her lies and falsehoods. Today Al Roker Gets Fans Excited In Cute Attire, Ben Seewald Rushes To Jessas Defense Amid Insensitive Attacks, Alaskan Bush People Noah Brown Celebrates Milestone, Justin Bieber Cancels Remainder Of Tour Amid His Wifes Drama, Kanye Wests Former Flame Shares Where She Came From, Ryan Seacrests Young Girlfriend Stuns In Seriously Small Bikini, Amy King Neglects To Shield Daxton From Immediate Danger. 2004). Your email address will not be published. Josh Duggars Wife Anna Takes Kids & Leaves The Country? This matter comes before the Court on a Motion to Dismiss filed by Defendants Katie Joy Paulson and Without a Crystal Ball, LLC ("Defendants"), and on a Motion for Sanctions, also filed by Defendants. Her company, Defendant Without a Crystal Ball, is a Minnesota limited liability company. Wash. 2010) ("One clear import of the Ninth Circuit's case law regarding express aiming is that the district court's inquiry on this score must be grounded squarely in the facts of the particular case."). Where the "[p]laintiff does not identify any evidence that Defendant specifically targets or solicits [forum-state] viewers," the forum-state "residents' ability to view Defendant's online content" alone is not enough to demonstrate express aiming. Personal jurisdiction may be general or specific. Also unlike the article in Calder, which was focused on Jones' activities in the forum, Defendants' videos do not refer in any substantive way to activities conducted in Washington. Uploaded by P. 12(b)(2) for lack of personal jurisdiction. IF it is in journalism (doubt it) then I will credit her as a journalist. Sugar [17], Since October 20, 2020, Westbrook and her husband, James, are . 1-1. I hope she crawls back into the cesspool she crawled out of. Vater Tochter Geschichten - Das Freudenmdchen seite6. Tati Westbrook, 13th Annual Women In Film Female Oscar Nominees Party "This was just really mind-blowing to have happen," she explained, adding the ongoing litigation is the reason she did not . . Her real name is Katie. However, Tati wanted to be a bigger part of the company as she was also the spokesperson for it, and that if that happened she would release any products under the Halo Beauty roof. . UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT WESTERN DISTRICT OF WASHINGTON AT SEATTLE. WITHOUT A CRYSTAL BALL, LLC, a Minnesota Limited Liability Company; and DOES 1 through 100, inclusive, Defendants. Suck it up and move on! I would never follow this Katie Joy yet when scrolling Ill read a preposterous heading and it will be written by her and I find her nothing more than a daily bully online! I just worry what all extra stress this will bring and hope it doesnt as I feel for little man so much and no one would want to see a parent suffer even if its self inflicted. In Calder, the "reputation-based effects . Having reviewed the parties' briefs in support of and in opposition to the motions, the relevant exhibits and case law, and the remainder of the record, the Court grants Defendants' Motion to Dismiss for lack of personal jurisdiction, and denies Defendants' Motion for Sanctions. The plan was to build a nutraceuticals company that would sell ingestibles with health benefits. She should be removed from YouTube. This is in contrast to the situation in Calder, where the Court reviewed "the various facts that gave the article a California focus," and concluded "California is the focal point [] of the story."). Plaintiffs argue that Paulson must have used Washington-specific websites in her research, a reasonable inference from the content of her videos. But it doesnt seem to end sometime soon, so stay tuned for more updates! He noted they didn't fear them as he considered going to court to be a sport. Last edited: Jan 28, 2021. It is not clear from the case law what distinction, if any, is intended between the phrases "purposely directed" and "expressly aimed," but for purposes of this case, because Defendants have not challenged the first and third prongs, the effects test effectively collapses into the first prong of the "minimum contacts" test. And this is how the "Without a Crystal Ball Lawsuit" came to happen! 1982); see also In re Keegan Mgmt. by fizzwizz12 Tue Nov 03, 2020 9:58 am, Post She tweeted that Lindsie Chrisley was NOT a person who needed someone to be her mouth piece. She pointed out that Lindsie has a huge following and two podcasts. Coming for someone who is dealing with a complex kid with medical and behavioral issues is low even for Ali. Career YouTube. No. Westbrook put Charles on blast after a deal he struck at Coachella. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. of Miami-Dade Cty. as well as other partner offers and accept our. Does anyone know of lawsuits for emotional distress that actually stick? 4. (LH), NOTICE of Docket Text Modification re #41 Declaration, #40 Declaration, #39 MOTION for Status Conference: Modified #39 to convert REQUEST into a MOTION. Todd Chrisley was quick to debunk everything Katie Joy had to say on his next podcast after news broke. Defendants' Motion for Sanctions is DENIED without prejudice. But after two years, the content creator is shutting down her beauty business. She, however, stood her ground on the fact that she wasnt afraid to go to court against Todd Chrisley. Share to Twitter. Blogger. Decl. Post by Jesters Trix Tue Nov 10, 2020 11:04 am. Cal. However, she realized that many fans "want answers about certain things .